Case details

Print
Anticompetitive practices
Case reference
PRC/2005/4
Entities involved
  • Abbott Laborários, Lda.
  • BAYER Diagnostics Europe, Lda.
  • Bayer Portugal, SA
  • Johnson & Johnson
  • Menarini Diagnósticos - Material de Laboratório, Lda.
  • Roche Farmacêutica Química, Lda
Natural persons involved
No
Sector
  • Health & Pharmaceutical
  • Public Procurement 
Activity (NACE)
  • G464 - Wholesale of household goods, except food, beverages and tobacco
Investigated practice
  • Horizontal agreement
Legal provisions
  • National-Law 18/2003-Article 4
Case origin
Ex-officio
Dawn raids
No
Cooperation with sector regulators
  • ERS - Health Regulatory Entity
Status
Closed
AdC’s decision
Sanctioning decision
Settlement
Sanction imposed
  • Abbott Laborários, Lda. - €7,000,000.00
  • BAYER Diagnostics Europe, Lda. - €5,200,000.00
  • Bayer Portugal, SA - €2,997,000.00
  • Johnson & Johnson - €658,413.22
  • Menarini Diagnósticos - Material de Laboratório, Lda. - €2,812,022.22
Summary of the case

Case opened, on 10.02.2005, on its own initiative, based on a concerted practice in the pharmaceutical sector, involving 5 laboratories, in which prices were fixed in several hospital public tenders for the supply of blood glucose test strips.

Sufficient evidence was gathered which led to the five pharmaceutical companies being charged with concerted practices consisting of submitting uniform prices in 36 public tenders for the supply of 22 hospitals.

On 10.01.2008, the Supervisor's Council issued a condemnatory decision.

It should be noted that, following the adoption of a first conviction decision by the Competition Authority on 25.11.2005, and an appeal by the defendants, the Commerce Court annulled the process up to the Statement of Objections, on defence nullity grounds, repeating all procedures from the Statement of Objections onwards.

Timeline
2016-06-06
2008-01-17
2008-01-10
2005-10-13
2005-10-06
Statement of objections
2005-02-10
Case initiation
Judicial phase chronology - Interlocutory appeals
Judicial phase chronology - Final decision appeal
2016-03-09
Constitutional Court
IDF/2008/1
Autos de recurso n.º 1052/2015
2016-01-12
Constitutional Court
IDF/2008/1
Autos de recurso n.º 1052/2015
2015-11-11
Lisbon Court of Appeal
IDF/2008/1
350/08.8TYLSB.L3
2015-10-14
Lisbon Court of Appeal
IDF/2008/1
350/08.8TYLSB.L3
2015-07-15
Lisbon Court of Appeal
IDF/2008/1
350/08.8TYLSB.L3
2015-01-08
Competition, Regulation and Supervision Court
IDF/2008/1
350/08.8TYLSB
2014-11-18
Competition, Regulation and Supervision Court
IDF/2008/1
350/08.8TYLSB
2014-06-11
Constitutional Court
IDF/2008/1
Autos de recurso n.º 588/2013
2013-10-07
Constitutional Court
IDF/2008/1
Autos de recurso n.º 366-B/2011
2013-07-30
Constitutional Court
IDF/2008/1
Autos de recurso n.º 588/2013
2013-04-10
Lisbon Court of Appeal
IDF/2008/1
350/08.8TYLSB.L2
2013-02-06
Lisbon Court of Appeal
IDF/2008/1
350/08.8TYLSB.L2
2012-11-19
Lisbon Court of Appeal
IDF/2008/1
350/08.8TYLSB.L1
2012-07-17
Lisbon Commercial Court
IDF/2008/1
350/08.8TYLSB
2012-03-30
Lisbon Commercial Court
IDF/2008/1
350/08.8TYLSB
2012-02-08
Constitutional Court
IDF/2008/1
Autos de recurso n.º 366-B/2011
2012-01-04
Constitutional Court
IDF/2008/1
Autos de recurso n.º 366-B/2011
2011-12-21
Constitutional Court
IDF/2008/1
Autos de recurso n.º 366-A/2011
2011-11-30
Constitutional Court
IDF/2008/1
Autos de recurso n.º 366-B/2011
2011-11-25
Constitutional Court
IDF/2008/1
Autos de recurso n.º 366-A/2011
2011-11-09
Constitutional Court
IDF/2008/1
Autos de recurso n.º 366/2011
2011-11-08
Constitutional Court
IDF/2008/1
Autos de recurso n.º 366/2011
2011-10-11
Constitutional Court
IDF/2008/1
Autos de recurso n.º 366/2011
2011-07-14
Constitutional Court
IDF/2008/1
Autos de recurso n.º 366/2011
2011-06-09
Constitutional Court
IDF/2008/1
Autos de recurso n.º 366/2011
2011-03-30
Lisbon Court of Appeal
IDF/2008/1
350/08.8TYLSB.L1
2010-12-15
Lisbon Court of Appeal
IDF/2008/1
350/08.8TYLSB.L1
2010-01-07
Lisbon Commercial Court
IDF/2008/1
350/08.8TYLSB
2007-07-05
Lisbon Commercial Court
IDF/2005/17
1697/05.0TYLSB
2007-04-26
Lisbon Commercial Court
IDF/2005/17
1697/05.0TYLSB
Click here to see your activities